Fred Pearce
guardian.co.uk,
Monday 1 February 2010
Phil Jones, the beleaguered British climate scientist at the centre of the leaked emails controversy, is facing fresh claims that he sought to hide problems in key temperature data on which some of his work was based.
A Guardian investigation of thousands of emails and documents apparently hacked from the University of East Anglia's climatic research unit has found evidence that a series of measurements from Chinese weather stations were seriously flawed and that documents relating to them could not be produced.
Jones and a collaborator have been accused by a climate change sceptic and researcher of scientific fraud for attempting to suppress data that could cast doubt on a key 1990 study on the effect of cities on warming – a hotly contested issue.
Today the Guardian reveals how Jones withheld the information requested under freedom of information laws. Subsequently a senior colleague told him he feared that Jones's collaborator, Wei-Chyung Wang of the University at Albany, had "screwed up".
The revelations on the inadequacies of the 1990 paper do not undermine the case that humans are causing climate change, and other studies have produced similar findings. But they do call into question the probity of some climate change science.
The apparent attempts to cover up problems with temperature data from the Chinese weather stations provide the first link between the email scandal and the UN's embattled climate science body, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, as a paper based on the measurements was used to bolster IPCC statements about rapid global warming in recent decades.
Wang was cleared of scientific fraud by his university, but new information brought to light today indicates at least one senior colleague had serious concerns about the affair.
It also emerges that documents which Wang claimed would exonerate him and Jones did not exist.
The revelations come at a torrid time for climate science, with the IPPC suffering heavy criticism for its use of information that had not been rigorously checked – in particular a false claim that all Himalayan glaciers could melt by 2035 – and UEA having been criticised last week by the deputy information commissioner for refusing valid requests for data under the Freedom of Information Act.
The Guardian has learned that of 105 freedom of information requests to the university concerning the climatic research unit (CRU), which Jones headed up to the end of December, only 10 had been released in full.
The temperature data from the Chinese weather stations measured the warming there over the past half century and appeared in a 1990 paper in the prestigious journal Nature, which was cited by the IPCC's latest report in 2007.
Climate change sceptics asked the UEA, via FOI requests, for location data for the 84 weather stations in eastern China, half of which were urban and half rural.
The history of where the weather stations were sited was crucial to Jones and Wang's 1990 study, as it concluded the rising temperatures recorded in China were the result of global climate changes rather the warming effects of expanding cities.
The IPCC's 2007 report used the study to justify the claim that "any urban-related trend" in global temperatures was small. Jones was one of two "coordinating lead authors" for the relevant chapter.
The leaked emails from the CRU reveal that the former director of the unit, Tom Wigley, harboured grave doubts about the cover-up of the shortcomings in Jones and Wang's work. Wigley was in charge of CRU when the original paper was published. "Were you taking W-CW [Wang] on trust?" he asked Jones. He continued: "Why, why, why did you and W-CW not simply say this right at the start?"
Jones said he was not able to comment on the story.
Wang said: "I have been exonerated by my university on all the charges. When we started on the paper we had all the station location details in order to identify our network, but we cannot find them any more.
"Some of the location changes were probably only a few metres, and where they were more we corrected for them."
In an interview with the Observer on Sunday Ed Miliband, the climate change secretary, warned of the danger of a public backlash against mainstream climate science over claims that scientists manipulated data. He declared a "battle" against the "siren voices" who denied global warming was real or caused by humans. "It's right that there's rigour applied to all the reports about climate change, but I think it would be wrong that when a mistake is made it's somehow used to undermine the overwhelming picture that's there," he said.
Last week the Information Commissioner's Office – the body that administers the Freedom of Information Act – said the University of East Anglia had flouted the rules in its handling of an FOI request in May 2008.
Days after receiving the request for information from the British climate change sceptic David Holland, Jones asked Prof Mike Mann of Pennsylvania State University in the United States: "Can you delete any emails you may have had with Keith [Briffa] re AR4? Keith will do likewise.
"Can you also email Gene [Eugene Wahl, a paleoclimatologist in Boulder, Colorado] and get him to do the same ... We will be getting Caspar [Ammann, also from Boulder] to do the same."
The University of East Anglia says that no emails were deleted following this exchange.
Printable versionSend to a friendShareClipContact us larger smaller EmailClose Recipient's email address Your first name Your surname Add a note (optional)
Your IP address will be logged
ShareClose Diggreddit Google Bookmarks Twitter del.icio.us StumbleUpon Newsvine livejournal Facebook Mixx it! Contact usClose Contact the Environment editor
environment@guardian.co.uk Report errors or inaccuracies: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Letters for publication should be sent to: letters@guardian.co.uk If you need help using the site: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Call the main Guardian and Observer switchboard:
+44 (0)20 3353 2000 Advertising guide License/buy our content EnvironmentClimate change · Climate change scepticism ScienceClimate change UK newsWorld newsMore news More on this storyMoving weather posts and a scientist under siege
Fred Pearce: How 'climategate' scandal is bogus
David King backs off on climate hacking
Related
7 Dec 2009The climate denial industry is out to dupe the public. And it's working George Monbiot
23 Nov 2009Global warming rigged? Here's the email I'd need to see George Monbiot
16 Nov 2009Top 10 Tory bloggers disagree with David Cameron on climate change
17 Sep 2009China's top climatologist stays cool over 2C rise
Printable versionSend to a friendShareClipContact usArticle history
EmailClose Recipient's email address Your first name Your surname Add a note (optional)
Your IP address will be logged
ShareClose Diggreddit Google Bookmarks Twitter del.icio.us StumbleUpon Newsvine livejournal Facebook Mixx it!
Contact usClose Contact the Environment editor
environment@guardian.co.uk Report errors or inaccuracies: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Letters for publication should be sent to: letters@guardian.co.uk If you need help using the site: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Call the main Guardian and Observer switchboard:
+44 (0)20 3353 2000 Advertising guide License/buy our content
About this articleClose Leaked climate change emails scientist 'hid' data flawsThis article was published on guardian.co.uk at 21.00 GMT on Monday 1 February 2010. It was last modified at 22.46 GMT on Monday 1 February 2010. Latest from environmentMost viewed Latest Most commented Last 24 hours
1. Global deal on climate change in 2010 'all but impossible' 2. Leaked climate change emails scientist 'hid' data flaws 3. Ed Miliband declares war on climate change sceptics 4. Rajendra Pachauri fails to get British support over 'unsubstantiated' climate report claims 5. David King admits to speculation over source of climate science emails More top stories Chances of Copenhagen climate talks 'rematch' unlikely, say experts Leaked emails scientist 'hid' data flaws 'Climategate' claims based on lies All today's storiesLast 24 hours
1. Ed Miliband declares war on climate change sceptics (786 comments) 2. James Delingpole leads Telegraph into vicious climate over email George Monbiot (330) 3. Leaked climate change emails scientist 'hid' data flaws (270) 4. How the 'climategate' scandal is bogus and based on climate sceptics' lies Fred Pearce (134) 5. David King admits to speculation over source of climate science emails (84) Green shopping Choc-Affair Orange Chocolate
These chocolate are individually wrapped, and elegantly presented in a reusable jar.
Heat sensitive CO2 Mug
The colours change to reveal the world's most severe carbon footprint offenders!
Most viewed on guardian.co.uk24 hours 7 days 24 hours1. US raises stakes on Iran by sending in ships and missiles 2. Transfer deadline day - as it happened! 3. Charlie Brooker iPad therefore iWant? Probably. Why? iDunno 4. How Bush's grandfather helped Hitler's rise to power 5. Pope condemns gay equality laws ahead of first UK visit More top stories 7 days1. US raises stakes on Iran by sending in ships and missiles 2. Transfer deadline day - as it happened! 3. The boy who paints like an old master 4. How Bush's grandfather helped Hitler's rise to power 5. The Apple tablet: the experts' view More top stories Free P&P at the Guardian bookshop Natural Hazards£42.99 with free UK delivery Global Warming£24.99 with free UK deliveryBrowse more nature and science books Buy books from the Guardian Bookshop Sponsored features UK USA UK Browse environment jobs
Senior Environmental Consultantallen & york.
uae.
£4724 - £5906 or 28000AED - 35000AED.
Green Infrastructure Consultantthe environment partnership llp.
north west england.
Negotiable.
Health & Safety Managerallen & york.
our client is a large corporate with interests thr….
£30k - £33k.
USA Browse environment jobs
{for result in results}
${result.jobtitle}
${ result.snippet }
${ result.state }
{/for}
Emerging Leaders in Science Program — R&D Pipeline Optimization and Improvement s Emerging Leaders in Science PhD Rotational Program... to work in a heavily matrixed, team-based environment. Ability and willingness to relocate. Desired... MO
Emerging Leaders in Science Program — Genomics Strategies for Crop Improvement s Emerging Leaders in Science PhD Rotational Program... and desire to work in a heavily matrixed, team-based environment. Ability and willingness to relocate... MO
Emerging Leaders in Science Program — Application of Engineering for Crop Improvement s Emerging Leaders in Science PhD Rotational Program... production, and growing environments. This includes knowledge of field environment technologies such as... MO
jobs by
Ads by GoogleArtery Clearing SecretHugh Downs reports on breakthrough artery clearing secret.
www.bottomlinesecrets.com
Free Belize Fact SheetFor people considering Retiring, Visiting, or Living in Belize
www.InternationalLiving.com/Belize
Free Guardianship FormsMake your Free Guardianship Form Absolutely Free. Print, Sign & Save
RocketLawyer.com/Guardianship-Form
Related informationEnvironmentClimate change · Climate change scepticism ScienceClimate change UK newsWorld news
'If the governments sleep, let the people rise'
14 Dec 2009:
Green visions video: Dr Vandana Shiva in Copenhagen: Organic farming can play a key role in protecting the planet
More video
25 Jun 2009Climate science is by nature uncertain Adam Corner
20 May 2009George Monbiot: Price of doing nothing costs the earth
27 Apr 2009John Theodore Houghton: The truth about climate change
11 Aug 2008Letter: Denial lies at the heart of climate change policy
Monbiot's royal flush: Cut out and keep climate change denier cards
9 Mar 2009:
George Monbiot's top 10 climate change deniers - in cut out and keep card form
More galleries
License/buy our content Privacy policy Terms & conditions Advertising guide Accessibility A-Z index Inside guardian.co.uk blog About guardian.co.uk Join our dating site today
guardian.co.uk © Guardian News and Media Limited 2010
Go to: guardian.co.uk home UK news World news Comment is free blog Newsblog Sport blog Arts & Entertainment blog Audio & podcasts In pictures Video Archive search Arts & entertainment Books Business EducationGuardian.co.uk Environment Film Football Jobs Katine appeal Life & style MediaGuardian.co.uk Money Music The Observer Politics Science Shopping SocietyGuardian.co.uk Sport Talk Technology Travel Been there Subscription services Email services Special reports The Guardian The Northerner The Wrap Advertising guide Compare finance products Crossword Feedback Garden centre GNM Press Office Graduate Bookshop Guardian Ecostore Guardian Films Headline service Help / contacts Information Living our values Newsroom Notes & Queries Promotions Reader Offers Readers' editor Soulmates dating Style guide Syndication services Travel offers TV listings Weather Working for us Guardian Weekly Public Learn Guardian back issues Observer back issues Guardian Professional
No comments:
Post a Comment